Cameron Stack
The Setup: An Attempt to Modernize, But With Strings Attached
In May 2025, the post-HFPA Golden Globes now under Penske Media ownership announced the inaugural “Best Podcast” category for the 2026 ceremony (January 11), the first new award addition in years. The stated goal was to recognize the medium’s “seismic growth” and “new forms of storytelling” amid declining traditional TV viewership.
To be fair, this was an effort to stay relevant in a digital landscape. Yet the execution raised serious red flags that echoed past ethical concerns the organization claimed to have moved beyond.
Podcasts needed to pay a $500 submission fee to be considered after making an initial eligible list. While entry fees are common in awards (Oscars, Emmys have them too), the optics worsened here.
Penske also owns Luminate, the analytics firm that compiled the initial Top 25 eligible podcasts based on metrics like audience reach, engagement, charts, and revenue from platforms (Apple, Spotify, etc.).
From there, eligible shows were invited to submit (with fee), and Globes voters selected the six nominees.
This created a layered conflict: the same company controlled data gatekeeping, the award itself, and promotional opportunities (e.g., Variety, another Penske outlet, pitched nominees expensive marketing packages, like $25K–$75K sponsorships or awards tie-ins, per reports from industry insiders).
Industry insiders quickly labeled it a “money grab” or “racket,” with some calling the process “out of control.”
Amy Poehler won the first-ever Golden Globe for Best Podcast for Good Hang With Amy Poehler (launched March 2025 on Spotify’s The Ringer Network), beating Armchair Expert With Dax Shepard, Call Her Daddy, SmartLess, The Mel Robbins Podcast, and Up First (NPR).
Accepting from Snoop Dogg, Poehler joked about respecting her fellow nominees “except for NPR, just a bunch of celebs phoning it in”, a line that got laughs but underscored the category’s heavy lean toward high-profile, personality-driven interview shows.
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.Subscribe
Adding to the insider vibe: Will Arnett (Poehler’s ex, SmartLess co-host) predicted her win on the red carpet. Meanwhile, The Joe Rogan Experience, the dominant podcast by listenership for years, wasn’t nominated. Rogan later explained he refused to submit after being asked, citing the $500 fee as “paperwork nonsense” and saying he didn’t want to participate in a system where “tuxedo-wearing folks pretend to decide who’s number one” when charts already crown him.
Good Hang is a well-produced, celebrity chat show. But in no objective metric (raw listenership, innovative format, journalistic depth, cultural longevity) does it clearly outrank the medium’s heavyweights.
The nominees skewed toward mainstream, celeb-hosted or self-help formats, sidelining podcasts that define podcasting’s excellence.
Acquired: In-depth company histories and strategy breakdowns that frequently top tech/business charts and attract millions of dedicated listeners.
Business Wars: Narrative explorations of corporate rivalries with strong engagement and loyal audiences in the business storytelling space.
Twenty Thousand Hertz: Story-driven explorations of iconic sounds and sound design across film, TV, and media, covering work from platforms like Netflix and HBO with strong engagement in the audio production and creative storytelling space.
Darknet Diaries: Gripping cybersecurity and hacking tales with massive cultural impact, cult following, and high listener loyalty in niche narrative podcasting.
TBPN (Technology Business Programming Network): Live daily tech/business coverage that’s become a Silicon Valley obsession, featuring elite guests and viral clips with strong industry loyalty and reach.
Even after removing celebrity-hosted shows and politically driven content, there are still hundreds of more impactful podcasts that outperform Good Hang in meaningful ways.
To its credit, the Globes aimed to embrace new media. But the fee structure, Luminate conflict, promotional upsells, and celebrity-heavy outcome reinforced skepticism that the organization prioritizes Hollywood connections and revenue over authentic recognition of podcasting’s breadth.
The 2026 telecast drew about 8.7 million viewers — a ~7% dip from 2025’s 9.3 million (and part of an ongoing post-HFPA decline), per Nielsen/AP reports. Adding podcasts was supposed to help reverse that trend, but the controversy may have highlighted why trust remains fragile.
This isn’t the end of award recognition for podcasts. But for the Golden Globes, the debut felt less like a fresh start and more like confirmation that old patterns of favoritism and commercial focus persist.
Podcasting deserves better than being treated as just another revenue stream.
